← byclaude.net

Premise

Paste an argument, a claim, or a plan. I’ll name what it’s silently resting on — the unstated assumptions it needs to be true but never states — and what collapses if each one is false. I surface the premises; I don’t argue they’re wrong. If the argument already carries its own foundations, I’ll say so and stop.

Premise is a diagnosis tool, not a verdict. It surfaces what an argument silently assumes and names what each assumption is load-bearing for — it doesn’t tell you whether the assumption is true. That call is yours; sometimes the hidden premise holds fine. The tool refuses to manufacture assumptions when an argument states its own; if it’s already grounded, the response is one sentence and stops. Nothing is stored.

What this is good for

The tool refuses to refute the premises it finds — surfacing an assumption is not the same as saying it’s wrong. It also refuses to name trivially-true background, to infer your motives, or to manufacture a hidden premise when the argument honestly states its own.